Saturday, November 21, 2026

Bloody

I didn’t really expect Northwestern to win a game in Columbus, something I and I assume most of the readers of this blog have never been alive to see, but the possibility was tantalizing for much longer than I imagined. They were right there within a touchdown late until a devastating punt muff functionally ended the game and led to a third consecutive loss for the ‘Cats and a win for Ohio State that took a simmering fanbase from operatic fury and demands to fire every coach to operatic fury and demands to fire every coach.


Ohio State fans after the Buckeyes lose a game 

Ohio State played the game with what I think was the first gameplan I’ve ever seen entirely devoted to the idea “that ought to hold the little S.O.B.s.” Ohio State fans have been, according to the Connor Onion/Robert Griffin III announcing crew that has been inexplicably handcuffed to this Northwestern team like a mob henchman guarding a mysterious briefcase, shrieking about the team not giving the ball to superstar wide receiver Jeremiah Smith enough, so a fed up Ryan Day had them throwing the ball to him on pretty much every play. It would have been funny if that had blown up on them the way a bored Wisconsin team would sometimes get sick of handing the ball off for twelve yards a carry and demand that their oafish Wisconsin-style quarterback try to throw the ball exactly enough times for Northwestern to upset them, but unfortunately it turns out that getting the ball to the best player in the country is going to eventually work pretty well.

Northwestern’s offense continued to struggle since the second half of the Oregon game. This was not because of the efforts of Bloody Nicco Marchiol, who plays quarterback like he is fending off a bear attack. He reminds me of the scene in Project Grizzly where insane Canadian inventor Troy Hortubise builds a suit in order to make him invulnerable to grizzly bear attacks for a reason that he is never really able to articulate and tests it by having his friends hit him with bats, use ewok-style rope and tree techniques to hit him with a flying tree trunk, drive a pickup truck into him, and throw him down an escarpment. 

It is hard not to admire someone who is playing quarterback like this. Marchiol was throwing the ball well, has yet to turn it over while being sandwiched by two enormous guys, and is constantly scrambling with reckless abandon, but I am curious to see what he looks like in an offense where he is not fleeing. Chiles has already been ruled out for the next game, but I also think that the problems with Northwestern’s offense that include a running game that has been shut down by quality Big Ten opponents and an offensive line that looks at times like they have been fooled by Odysseus and are welcoming defensive linemen into the backfield, are not because Nicco Marchiol has several plays each game where he looks like Indiana Jones running from the giant ball as soon as it’s snapped. Northwestern needs Chiles to be great, but with Marchiol I believe they can still be good.

I'm Johnny Knoxville and this is "Play Football For The Northwestern Wildcats"

This stretch of games– at Oregon, home to a pain-in-the-ass Iowa team, at Ohio State– seemed like an unwinnable death stretch the second the schedule came out. I never really expected them to win any of these games. But with Oregon and Ohio State looking as beatable as they have been and are likely to be, the 0-3 stretch and going from 6-1 to 6-4 in an instant feels pretty bad. The possibility of losing out, losing Chiles, and going out sad and Hatless is now a possible sad ending to the season, even if getting to bowl eligibility with this schedule seemed like a dream scenario.

MINNESOTA

One day there perhaps will be a small group that splinters from civilization in a series of far-flung dwellings and ornate caves evolving into a civilization of scholar-monks dedicated to the question: are the Minnesota Golden Gophers good at football. Minnesota has managed to reclaim a large number of sought-after trophies by defeating Iowa and Michigan and hang tough against Indiana. It is also a team that was just blown out by a wretched Penn State team and fired its offensive coordinator.  

Minnesota is 5-5 and playing for its bowl life before a showdown with an inscrutable Wisconsin team. Last year, that was Northwestern in that position, managing to barely eke out a win on a missed field goal to secure a bowl berth in Detroit in a “home game” at Wrigley Field that was mostly made up of depressed Gopher fans who foolishly thought they were attending a winnable game on the road (Minnesota had to that point lost all of its road games). 

Minnesota is a step down in competition from the likes of Oregon and Ohio State. With Chiles, I would think Northwestern would have the advantage, but with Marchiol this looks like a classic Big Ten West-style punt-off. On the other hand, that’s what I thought about last year’s game and it turned into an unexpected shootout with Preston Stone and Drake Lindsey trading bombs down the first base line. Maybe Marchiol can get into more of a rhythm if he is not actively being smashed into a fine paste; on the other hand, maybe he can only feel alive as a quarterback if he spends most of the game being battered with his own limbs and does not know how to play football unless he feels like the guy who steps in a bear trap and while he is wailing in agony gets punched in the face by Walker Texas Ranger.

One dangerous wrinkle from Minnesota is the involvement of PJ Fleck in blood rituals. After the Gophers downed Washington, Fleck found a bleeding player and smeared his own face with his blood in triumph in an insane and disgusting celebration. It could have been PJ Fleck going nutso after a win or it could be something far more sinister, a practice he learned from an evil shaman that is triggered by blood and him reciting an incantation from the Acronymicon, a book that has been passed down from Fleck to Fleck from the time immemorial. 


A bloody-smeared PJ Fleck prepares to invoke the Forbidden Acronyms B.E.E.L.Z.E.B.U.B. and M.U.R.T.H.E.R. 

Fleck has also pretended to drink from the Little Brown Jug after defeating one of the most downtrodden Michigan teams we have ever seen– a Michigan team so bad that fans will be complaining about it for decades after 15 consecutive ten-win seasons– and also crowd surfing on Fox’s black lodge college gameday knockoff show.

  

Northwestern is facing a team for the second time this season right after they have fired the offensive coordinator. Before the Oregon game, I had wondered if this meant they were facing a team in disarray or if it meant that the opposing coordinator was so inept and shitty that their opponent would immediately bounce back. For Oregon, it could not be more clear that it was the latter. After weeks of looking lost and inept on offense, the new coordinator had Dylan Raiola throwing bombs on Northwestern’s shorthanded secondary, and Oregon has had a functioning offense since. Minnesota has been limited on offense more I think because of the state of being Minnesota than held back by a lousy coordinator, but we also have seen Drake Lindsey look like Kurt Warner against this defense, and the ‘Cats have not exactly been a fortress against the run.

Both of these teams desperately need this game. Minnesota wants to get bowl eligible and Northwestern wants to stop its skid down the Big Ten standings. If the ‘Cats can win this, they would face Illinois for the Hat and an eight-win season. But a continued plunge starting 6-1 would be devastating.

FICTION SECTION

I could tell from the second she knocked on the door it was going to be trouble. Lawyers like me can always tell, like how an old man’s knee starts to throb before a thunderstorm. But lawyers like me are not in a position to turn them down. 

She was tall. Volleyball, I guessed. Maybe basketball. “Are you Mr. Roaredly,” she asked, a catch in her voice. “I could be, for the right price,” I said. The door said Barris Roaredly, Esq. Or at least it did until a baseball player threw a ball right through it. It was a disagreement. I thought we were arguing over money, he thought it was a debate over whether he could throw a fastball through my skull. It turned out to be more of a cutter. I guess that’s why he didn’t make it out of A ball.

“Mr. Roaredly, I’m in a dreadful state,” she said. 

“So am I,” I said. She squinted. She was looking around the dingy office, having second thoughts. I didn’t blame her. I was in the middle of cleaning the place up, which meant that only half of the case files were spilled out onto the floor under a special system I had devised that involves going through the pile and whispering unutterable curses. I needed to reel her back. I was being a little too hardboiled.

“How can I be of service?” I asked. I grabbed a legal pad from the bottom drawer and casually flipped to a page that wasn’t covered in tic tac toes. I had been playing myself and losing badly.

“It was set up. It’s a beastly thing,” she said. “I follow the rules. I would never–” she began to sob. I handed her a handkerchief, but she saw where it came from, declined, and pulled a tissue from her bag. 

The people who come to my office have never done anything wrong and they’re right about 20% of the time. Most of the time it depends on your definition of the word “wrong” but the one that counts belongs to the NCAA. Time was they’d lay you out a wayward burrito. I always told my clients to eat the evidence. But this was a different time. It was NIL. You could have a whole burrito restaurant. 

Eventually she spilled her guts. It was a volleyball team. Her name was Venus St. Blaire. One of her teammates, Madison Del Veranda, took her to a party. That’s where she met Urusula Mant. All conference Ursula Mant at State across town. The three became fast friends, making the scene at volleyball clinics and offseason training. But what she didn’t know was that these clinics were paying Mant more than it cost to tell an eight year-old not to be afraid of a spike coming over the net. They were trying to get her over to their team. They found volleyballs inflated with money. 

It was classic tampering, pretty much the only thing the NCAA can nail you for. And they came in hot. It was a predawn raid on the volleyball facility. There were shorts everywhere. I figured it was Ed Grack, who hadn’t had a lot to do over the last few years other than read those NCAA enforcement magazines and order the tactical gear out of the back of it. There was nothing tactical about Ed Grack in my opinion. He looked like stuffed olive in that gear, strongarming a punter over a moped, when we last tangled in court.

I told her I’d take her case. She didn’t realize I’d take any case. Very few people were trying to prove their innocence to the NCAA these days. I told her to give me a few days because I wanted to nose around. I knew it wouldn’t be good for me, but I also knew the whiskey wasn’t good for me, and that didn’t stop me from knocking down a few. 

I figured I’d talk to this Madison Del Veranda. Venus St. Blaire told me that she hangs out at a volleyball club called Spike’s off campus. It was the morning and the lot was sprinkled with a few cars. The guy at the door didn’t like my rumpled suit. 

“Sir, guests to the club require athletic attire,” he said.

“You have no idea how much I’ve run in this,” I said as I shouldered past him. “I’m not here to play, I’m a lawyer.”

“What sort of law do you practice?” 

“I sue clubs for sartorial discrimination.” 

By then I was halfway down the hallway. No one came after me. The main area downstairs was a network of courts while it looked like there were some private offices and lounges upstairs for more serious volleyball business. Most of them were empty, but I heard some volleyball noises coming from a small court in the corner. 

There was a woman in there with a rack of volleyballs throwing them in the air and blasting them over the net one by one. She was tall, dressed in volleyball clothes, and looked exactly like the person in the photos Venus had shown me on her phone.

“Madison Del Veranda?” I said. 

She looked at me and raised an eyebrow.

“Don’t come on the court with those hideous shoes, you’ll mark it up” she said walking off the court leaving the balls scattered and rolling to a stop all over the court.

“Yes, I’m Madison Del Veranda. Are you here from some sort of hobo association? Did someone leave a chalk marking on the wall?”

“No, they changed the symbols without telling me. I’m a lawyer, representing Venus St. Blaire. Barris Roardedly.”

She was sweating and took a long pull of water out of one of those giant bottles, the biggest one I've ever seen without effort. She looked like she could lift an entire water tower.  “Oh poor thing. The NCAA is really knocking her around.” She looked at me and my suit. “I had no idea she was in such dire straits.”

“I’m the guy you hire to knock back. She says you were there with her a lot. With her and Mant. Said you were a real barbershop trio. Did you know what was going on?”

“Barbershops come in quartets, but you don't seem particularly acquainted with barbers. It's dreadful, dreadful business with Venus. I wouldn’t know anything about it. I liked Ursula. A little troubled, both of them really, you could tell something was going on, but I don't ask questions. I don't nose around where I'm not wanted. I follow the rules, Mr. Roaredly. And I suggest you do too.”

The doorman had returned with two rectangles in tank tops.

“Sir, you’re in violation of the club dress code. You’ve already marked… look at that one. Look at that mark. Look at it, Robb! Take a picture of it!” One of the rectangles fumbled with a phone and took a picture of some sort of microscopic mark on the floor. “Sir, my associates would like to escort you from the premises.”

“That’s ok, I can escort myself. I’m familiar with the escorting out procedures.”

I walked out of the club with the manager following behind giving me the business with his eye until I walked into the sunshine beating down on the lot.

I had parked in the back. I always do at these places, not wanting someone to two my car because it looked like my car. I drove back to the office and parked in the alley. There was someone there to greet me.

The man was in a much nicer suit than mine, the kind that doesn’t get you escorted out of most places. Slick hair, handkerchief in the pocket, briefcase. 

“Mr. Roaredly,” he said. “I have heard that you have an interest in the St. Blaire case. You’ve been asking a lot of questions,” he said.

“You’ve been making a lot of statements,” I said. 

“I’m Tred Hoope. I’m also a lawyer. My client who I do not wish to disclose is involved in this case. We need to talk.”

“Makes sense. This alley is where I have all of my legal conversations.”

“Mr. Roaredly, I’d like to advise you that it be a good idea for you not to take this case. My client is prepared to offer you a substantial sum to fire your client and wait for the next guy caught getting a burrito.”

“They don’t do burritos anymore,” I said. “You can in fact have a whole restau…” 

That’s when I heard the sound. It was a slap at first before the blow came. I didn’t like how this guy negotiated, but I didn’t have time to protest before a volleyball knocked me on the back of the head. I was ready to offer a few retorts of my own right to his solar plexus when another volleyball hit me in the stomach and next thing I knew I was on the ground, a hail of volleyballs raining down on me. I guess this is why people don’t like lawyers.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

The Iowa Speedbump

If you were to draw up a diagram for how Northwestern would lose to Iowa, you’d pretty much get the game we got Saturday night. The Hawkeyes acted as always like a boa constructor, wrapping around the offense until no one wants to play football anymore. The ‘Cats couldn’t run the ball at all, stalled out on the pass game, and were forced into a cascade of punts. Right when it seemed like Northwestern might have been able to find the tiniest fissure with a field goal, they immediately gave up an instantly touchdown on the ensuing kick return and any hope of a competitive game vanished.

There is a blueprint to stop Iowa and that is to undergo a Face/Off-style procedure where you become Iowa, become the thing you hate the most and turn into the very embodiment of your own enemy to your friends and loved ones by playing turgid defense and forcing them to punt until the game becomes a barrage of punts darkening the sky above Ryan field with the brown tint of a thousand punts, and you might also hope they fumble. Northwestern has done that before and managed to win some of the most disgusting football games ever legally sanctioned in the United States. 


When you must become a Ferentz 

But in order to do that, you have to match Iowa tackle for tackle and and exchange gnarly linebacking with them, and the ‘Cats could not do that. They let “Hollywood” Hank Brown (I have given him this nickname for his showy and fancy play, which in Iowa terms means completing more than one forward pass) march the Hawkeyes down the field with no resistance on the first drive and let human battering ram L.J. Phillips blast through the line. By the time Northwestern was able to figure out how to slow down the Iowa attack, the Hawkeyes already had all of the points they needed.

Northwestern’s offense was without its indispensable star Aidan Chiles, sitting with an undisclosed “upper body injury.” Backup Nicco Marchiol played admirably in his stead. He’s a mulleted crafty lefty who has seen a lot of college football. Chip Kelly trusted him to run all of the insane maniac plays that he’s installed in the offense this season. And when Iowa had bottled up the running game and locked down the receivers, Marchiol scrambled again and again, willing to get absolutely blown up by tacklers in a desperate attempt to gain any sort of yards in the sort of performance you see when you are playing Tecmo Super Bowl and the half-assed quarterback run is the only play available because the computer-controlled opponents now move twice as fast as your guys. 

Marchiol played, I think, well enough to beat a lot of the teams on Northwestern’s early schedule, the ones that would allow Northwestern to have any sort of running game. Based on last game Marchiol would be one of the better quarterbacks Northwestern has had since Clayton Thorson. But he was not Chiles. Northwestern with Marchiol seems like the type of team that can the ‘Cats to a bowl game; Chiles was the quarterback who seemed like it might be possible to dream a bit bigger in a year when the most annoying teams in the Big Ten are in the throes of meltdowns and there may have been room for a star quarterback and an offensive coordinator who appears to be spending his time studying gaelic football in order to feel alive could squeeze into the mix. Instead, the party crashing at the top of the conference will be left to UCLA while Northwestern fends for a win and a Hat.

OHIO STATE

Things are bad in Columbus. The football team has collapsed, the coach is on the hot seat, the fans have lost all hope in the program, and the season is completely lost. Ohio State is 6-3, will probably win at least nine games, and may even somehow still get into the playoffs based on how stupid and chaotic the top of the college football rankings have been.


As he becomes embattled, Ryan Day is retreating further into the Steven Seagal styling universe. We are two losses from Day wearing elaborate necklaces and orange sunglasses while claiming he is actually in a secret law enforcement organization that even the president doesn't know about

The way Ohio State fans root for their team seems completely joyless and insane to me. The team starts every season with future NFL stars at every position, with a rank of backups that are good enough to fill another top 25 roster, a full complement of expensive Famous Guy coaches, and an expectation to win a title every year. The second something goes off by a little– they do not beat a team by enough points, or another team scores a single touchdown on them, or they lose to Michigan but still win a national title, the fans go nuts and demand to fire the coach. Winning a national title seems more like a vindication for all of that psychosis and spite than a celebration; it’s a mentality to me that seems less like rooting for a sports team than being hunted for sport.

Ohio State lost its starting quarterback and has been in a funk, barely eking out a win over reigning national champion Indiana before doing the unthinkable and losing two games in a row to USC and Oregon. This is the first time Ohio State has lost back-to-back games in fifteen years, and both losses were to unranked teams. This team might be as bad as the 2004 team that won an unthinkably paltry eight games, one of which was the last time they were defeated by Northwestern and is now somehow 22 years ago.


It would be very cool to have a second Northwestern beats Ohio State picture 

Despite the fact that the Buckeyes are reeling into an unacceptable disaster that would rate as one of the best seasons in Northwestern’s recent history, they remain heavily favored at home. Chiles will miss another game; Ohio State’s losses have come against fellow Big Ten heavyweights with expensive rosters that are having down years. A Northwestern team that struggled to cover Iowa’s receivers has a tall task trying contain wideout Jeremiah Smith for a whole game unless there are the extremely funny weather conditions for the 2022 game where it was so windy and rainy it rendered passing impossible and gummed up Ohio State’s fine-tuned sports car passing attack and forced them to match Pat Fitzgerald’s Toyota Hilux style. They still won the game because they are Ohio State, but for more than an hour and half of real time, Ohio State fans suffering in late stage Ryan Field were enjoyably miserable. 

This time the action moves to Ohio State, where they can, as an ad circulating this week for an Ohio State bomber jacket emblazoned with the logo of what is apparently some sort of defense contractor says, "defend the 'shoe."

 

Northwestern will end up on national TV again, this time with the personal Ohio State broadcast crew on Big Noon Sunday. This means we will get Gus Johnson on the call, a man who I’m assuming has not watched a single second of Northwestern football in years and who I hope will come up with stupid nickname for Marchiol such as “Muskrat Marchiol.” “Here comes Muskrat Marchiol, slithering around the defense for a gain of a yard” is something Gus might yell or we might even get an echo of his most famous Northwestern call of all time “Touchdown Wisconsin!”

This is the second Northwestern game on Regular-Ass Fox in two weeks after three weeks in exile on Peacock. This has been the strangest broadcast schedule I can remember for the ‘Cats with five games on national, rabbit ears television, three on Peacock, and only one on Big Ten Network Regional Action. Fox’s night team of Connor Onion and Robert Griffin III has broadcast three Northwestern games this season, which is a lot of RGIII– in the last game, the first to have a little bit of autumn chill, he appeared in a hat that seemed to be modeled on one of Phil Spector’s insane wigs. He looked like he was coming across the steppe with his hoard to raid $25 gourmet sliders from the Great Chicago Food Experience.

 

RGIII to his haberdascher: Get me the Fur Nuclear Test  

If Ohio State does what I and everyone else expects them do to and wins this game easily, it is at least a small comfort that it will bring no joy or satisfaction to Ohio State fans, who at this point can only be appeased by firing Ryan Day and building an animatronic replica of him to be suspended in a cage over their stadium to be pelted with garbage as a warning to any future coach that might consider going more than one year without winning a national championship. If the ‘Cats somehow pull it off, if they somehow get their first win against them in decades and their first win in Columbus since fucking 1971, I probably have to go the hospital for laughing too hard.

FICTION SECTION

This season, everyone in college football is suing everyone all the time. This week, here is a scene from a tense courtroom drama.

THE PLAYERS 

R. Preston Hitch Manhitcher: Defense attorney for Moss Cross

Mack Branyant: NCAA Investigator

Judge: The judge

Phil Guarry: Attorney for the NCAA 

 

R. PRESTON “HITCH” MANHITCHER: State your name for the record, sir.

MACK BRANYANT: Mack Branyant. 

MANHITCHER: And what do you do for a living, sir?

BRANYANT: I’m a detective for the NCAA. Investigate impermissible benefits. 

MANHITCHER: Now, explain what you mean by impermissible benefits.

BRANYANT: The NCAA has rules for what athletes can and can’t accept. If they accept money from companies or individuals beyond the scope of the program they lose their amateur status. They can’t play ball.

MANHITCHER: And how do you investigate these types of claims?

BRANYANT: Standard techniques. Documents. Witnesses. I would expect an esteemed lawyer like you would know the basics of how an investigation works.

MANHITCHER: I would say I do. I would say I know an awful lot about investigations, things that a person like yourself would never even contemplate. However, I believe that the people in this courtroom need to understand the uh delicate mechanisms by which a fellow such as yourself would go about extracting information from parties that would wish to keep it hidden.

BRANYANT: I believe the people in this courtroom have seen TV shows.

MANHITCHER: Your honor?

JUDGE: Mr. Branyant, I’m going to ask you to make smart-aleck remarks in my courtroom.

MANHITCHER: I would like to establish, for the record, the various techniques that Mr. Branyant uses in his so-called investigations. Mr. Branyant, do you believe it is ethical to misrepresent yourself when gathering information that you can use against the subjects of your investigations?

BRANYANT: It is not illegal.

PHIL GUARRY: Objection, he’s asking hypotheticals.

JUDGE: Sustained.

MANHITCHER: So you’re OK with lying and disseminating as long as it is not legal. 

JUDGE: (bangs gavel) Mr. Manhitcher.

BRANYANT: The gavel banging means you’re not doing a great job.

JUDGE: That’s enough out of you, Mr. Branyant. I already warned you about smart-aleck remarks. In fact, I want you to think about this court room as an industrial clean room, you know the kind where you have to put on those special suits to prevent any sort of contamination, and the contamination in this case is smart-aleck remarks. This is a smart aleck free zone. And if you contaminate it, I will let you clean yourself up in a jail cell, do you understand me Mr. Branyant?

BRANYANT: Yes.

MANHITCHER: Of course your honor. I agree wholeheartedly with your policy about smart-alecks. Which is why I am being very thorough with this one here, which you can see is a grade-A certified prime smart…

JUDGE: Get on with it, Manhitcher.

MANHITCHER: Absolutely. I was merely establishing the type of character that Mr. Branyant is in order to illuminate it and set the scene for what it means for my client to have a person such as Mr. Branyant attempting to quote unquote investigate him. Mr. Branyant, we’ve established that you have no issue with misidentifying yourself. Perhaps it would be best if I cited a concrete example. Mr. Branyant do you recall your case against Chaveous Wilhelm? 

BRANYANT: Yes. Point guard. Had an entire wardrobe of couture leather. Not permissible from the NCAA. Not a good look for him either. 

MANHITCHER: Now would you say you represented yourself truthfully to Mr. Wilhelm?

BRANYANT: It was an undercover operation.

MANHITCHER: Yes. In fact we have a photo of you with Mr. Wilhelm at the Leather Hats Expo. Enter this as Exhibit A. A photo of Mr. Branyant passing himself off as Darren St. Mauve, a stylist and influencer who insinuated himself into the confidence of Mr. Wilhelm. Mr. Branyant, do you find it difficult to worm your way into someone’s life, lie to them, and betray them to the authorities in order to ruin their athletic career? Perhaps you enjoy it.

BRANYANT: In this case, I found it extremely uncomfortable.

MANHITCHER: Uncomfortable to turn on an ostensible friend, someone you came to like and respect all the while knowing that you could at a moment’s notice upend his life? Uncomfortable to live a lie, live in the fast lane with the fashion set? 

BRANYANT: It was mainly the pants. Have you ever worn leather pants, Mr. Manhitcher?

MANHITCHER: Only once and it was for a charity… that’s beside the point. What happened to Mr. Wilhelm? And what about violence? Do you have a problem with violence in resolving a case?

BRANYANT: I don’t like it. But I’ll defend myself.

MANHITCHER: I am going to read directly from your report. This is the Travis Wagstrel case. Do you remember that one?

BRANYANT: Exotic reptiles. Extremely impermissible.

MANHITCHER: Here’s a quote from the report. “The shop man said he didn’t like me asking so many questions. I saw he was looking for something in the corner of his eye and it looked like it wasn’t used in the reptile trades. More of a sporting good. ‘Actually I’ve got some rare slugs for you,’ I told him. ‘Is that so,’ he said. Hissed. I gave him two good ones right in the stomach. He slithered to the floor. Those weren’t so rare, in my line of work.” Is that accurate?

BRANYANT: Yes.

MANHITCHER: You punched a man in the stomach repeatedly?

BRANYANT: It’s what those in the reptile business call a quick strike.

MANHITCHER: Thank you. Do you remember the Chust Munck case?

BRANYANT: Punter. Someone gave him a truck.

MANHITCHER: According to your report “that’s when he kicked me. I’ve been kicked before but this man was an artist.” Is that correct? And how did you describe it?

BRANYANT: I wish he was into something more abstract. But what he hit me with was perfectly rendered.

JUDGE: Mr. Manhitcher can you get on with it?

MANHITCHER: And how did you obtain this photo of the defendant Moss Cross getting what you claim is a burrito paid for by Mr. Ballace “Hog” Hogge?

BRANYANT: I walked by them and took a picture with my phone.

Saturday, November 7, 2026

Northwestern Gets Ducked

Northwestern was riding high coming into Eugene after crushing Rutgers, ripping out the heart of Pat Fitzgerald’s Michigan State team, and flaunting its ridiculous Chip Kelly offense over the largely ugly and inept offenses of the Big Ten. Last season, Northwestern was fighting for a bowl game for weeks. The bowl-eligible ‘Cats came into this game with unimaginable possibilities in the conference and maybe even dreams of the playoff. And for a half, it seemed like it was actually happening.

Northwestern started the game on fire on offense. Aidan Chiles was doing everything with his arm and his legs. The Oregon offense, which had continued its pattern of juddering mediocrity, kept stalling out. Kelly was once again cooking, sending out a new insane formation that was like an offset I-formation with receivers that I’ve never seen that so bamboozled the Oregon defense that they let Griffin Wilde sneak through completely alone for a 64-yard touchdown. The camera cut to sad Oregon fans watching a season that they started with national championship aspirations move from indignity to indignity, in this case getting demolished by a team they’ve never imagined losing to beating them with an insane, fever-dream offense designed by the coach who is significantly responsible for making Oregon into a national power while they are dressed like bananas and power rangers. With a minute remaining in the second half, the ‘Cats were up 20-6.

 

Your worst nightmare if you are linebacker who likes formations you have ever seen before 

Then, disaster. Dylan Railoa launched a bomb to Evan Stewart to set up a touchdown in the dying minutes of the first half to get the Ducks within a touchdown. And in the second half, they absolutely clobbered the ‘Cats. Oregon’s hulking defensive line took over the game, shutting down Northwestern’s running game and then, as the Northwestern lead dissolved, clobbering Chiles. On offense, Raiola suddenly turned into the star quarterback he had been when he was recruited to Nebraska and got more attention for attempting to will himself into becoming Patrick Mahomes by trying to look as much like him as possible and instead coming across like the ineffectual Hockey Pad Batman. After a lousy first half, it was as if someone had said a code word and activated his programming from all of those Manning Passing Academy minicamps and he was doing moves you would not believe by throwing to receivers getting open against Northwestern’s injury-riddled secondary.

 

Peyton Manning activates the "Eli Protocols" by using the codewords "Yes I'll Do That Commercial"

The second half was a dispiriting slog. The ‘Cats managed two field goals as the offense winnowed down to hoping Chiles could drag them up and down the field singlehandedly. The Oregon line squeezed him like a vice as the game went on while the Ducks offense gobbled up yards in big, thirsty gulps. The big blow came on a 75 yard touchdown pass in the fourth quarter. The Ducks were only up by eight, but Chiles and the offense could not bring back the last-second Michigan State heroics as the Oregon line turned him into the whac-a-mole game's titular mole.

The loss was frustrating; it is never fun to blow a large lead against a team in the midst of an angst-spiral that has just fired a coordinator and has already blown the chance to go to the playoff. And while the loss shatters a lot of the Wildcats' momentum and got them stripped of their national ranking, there’s still an opportunity to have an incredible season.

It is unclear what successful football seasons look like anymore for teams like Northwestern. For big programs like Oregon, there is an expectation to make the playoff and go deep and anything short of that seems like a failure. For Northwestern, the goal was always to make a bowl game and occasionally tunnel through 500 yards of shit-smelling foulness in the Big Ten West to make it to Indianapolis. But in 2026, teams don’t really care that much about bowl games as players understandably sit out to avoid imperiling a payday in the NFL or the transfer portal, and these games become glorified scrimmages between the ends of various benches that offer at best the opportunity to kill and eat a mascot or baptize a coach in mayonnaise. Some teams like Notre Dame have haughtily decided they will simply not even play in a bowl game if they don't make the playoff, like they are better than participating in a toaster snack cannibalization ritual just because they were really good in the 1920s. But a bowl game is good enough for me; I’m ecstatic for every bowl game the ‘Cats make even if no one else cares about them anymore.


The dream is to make it to a bowl game and then triumphantly hold up a fake newspaper from something called "Ford Field Times" printed on legal sized computer paper 

THE SAME FUCKING IOWA TEAM EVERY YEAR

If you are hypothetically writing a blog about Big Ten football, at some point it becomes harder and harder to come up with new and interesting things to say about Iowa football. Iowa is the most constant team in the Big Ten; they play the exact same way every year, they maintain a metronomic level Outback Bowl-caliber excellence, and the only thing that changes is determining the exact level of their disgusting offensive ineptitude, which can only be measured in the finest gradations; experts watch them with a jeweler's loupe to determine exactly how many microns their quarterback taken from the pile of discontinued models is off on his passes. Every season is Kirk Ferentz waking up to Sonny and Cher on a frozen Iowa City morning and living out the same day over and over again except he never learns or grows or takes piano lessons because the Groundhog Day scenario is a dream for him where he never has to do anything different and can just stand on the sidelines and squint while calling for the punting unit and then biting directly into a raw onion.

 

Scene from Groundhawk Day 

The frustrating thing about Iowa is that being this way, being the apex of disgusting punt-based trench football, being the least aesthetically pleasing brand of football ever concocted, is that this does not stop them from being very good. There was a brief period of time when Northwestern had their number and Pat Fitzgerald, huffing the very last fumes of the times Northwestern had a functioning offense with an army of plucky, undersized quarterbacks while the program slowly mutated into a putrid lesser version of Iowa football, was able to regularly frustrate the Hawks by defiantly punting at them. That time has passed. Iowa has kicked the absolute shit out of Northwestern the last few times they played; whatever burgeoning 2010s rivalry had been bubbling between these two programs has fully evaporated on the Iowa side while Northwestern fans desperately want to start beating them again.

This game seemed like it would offer a pretty exciting matchup of Chip Kelly's maniacal science lab offense versus the stoic Iowa defense in a race to 14 points. It promised the possibility of Ferentz staring disgustedly at wide receivers starting in Northwestern's own endzone or army crawling behind the line of scrimmage on TV cables. Iowa would probably be up for the task; we saw what happens last week when a team simply stops Northwestern's running game and eventually closes in on Chiles, but it is also possible that Ferentz would be so offended that he would be unable to contain his emotions and squint slightly harder.

Unfortunately, the dream of this matchup will not be fulfilled. Aidan Chiles, heroically reduced to being the only functioning member of Northwestern's offense by the end of last week's game, is now out with what Northwestern is describing cryptically as an "upper body injury" in a holdout from the Pat Fitzgerald regime's coded Moscow Rules-style injury reports. Northwestern has lost its wizard, the guy who makes the Chip Kelly offense work, and the best quarterback the 'Cats have had in decades. In previous years, quarterback injuries or benchings were not a huge deal because the Northwestern had a variety of quarterbacks who were all skilled and flawed in weird, mismatched ways so it would be interesting to see a running quarterback come in who couldn't pass or a guy who could throw it but had no way of escaping from pressure from dangerous Big Ten defensive lines or a guy who was a baseball player. Chiles is the Wildcats' indispensable player; without him it is difficult to imagine the 'Cats doing much of anything.

Northwestern does have a seasoned backup in Nicco Marichol who started for West Virginia. I have not seen a lot of Marichol, but he does represent a more experienced backup than a typical Northwestern second-stringer. But there is a fear that the Chip Kelly insanity playbook won't work as well without a guy who can run and throw with the accuracy of Chiles. Without its star quarterback, maybe Kelly's goofy shit won't be the solution against Iowa; it may be time to go into the bowels of Northwestern's football facility, recite the Forbidden Words, break the seal, and unlock the darkest arts of the Mick McCall playbook to try to win this game 5-2.

From the beginning of this season, it looked like this part of the schedule would be an impossible gantlet of misery. As it went on, Northwestern looked far better than I expected and these seemingly unstoppable juggernauts had flaws-- Oregon and Ohio State both lost their starting quarterbacks and have looked more vulnerable than they have in years. Beating any of them would be a tall task and any win would be one of greatest triumphs in program history. But all of that hope depended on this offense. Maybe Marichol will turn out to also be good at commanding Kelly's sorcerer's apprentice offense. Without Chiles, though, the rest of the season looks pretty bleak. 

FICTION SECTION

Dear Mr. Van Hiss,

This letter is to demand the urgent retraction of your ridiculous and libelous article "Inside Cudge Waynegetter's Controversial Plan To Take The 'Face Off' of College Football." In it, the author Brad Plaid alleges with no evidence that Coach Chadd "Cudge" Waynegetter was planning "an extensive program for high-performing professional athletes to return to the college ranks in disguise using techniques similar to the ones depicted in the 1997 John Woo film Face/Off." This is clearly a lie. No one on the State coaching staff or athletic department has ever proposed lasering off the face of a low depth chart professional football player and letting him play under an assumed name. My client, Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter, is prepared to file suit unless you replace the article with an apology immediately.

Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter is disgusted by the anonymous so-called "sources" in this article described as "sources close to the State football program" and "sources familiar with lasering someone's face off and giving them a new identity." These "sources" could be anyone including, as I would suspect, a long list of disgruntled former staff that Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter had to let go in order to "unclog this goddam toilet offense," many of whom have access to Face/Off through DVD or streaming video technology.

I understand that your scandal-mongering blogger Brad Plaid found some emails between my client Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter and a recently cut tackle from the Tennessee Titans with the subject matter "re: Face Laser." And yes, my client does not dispute that he, assuming the false name Ken "Kludge" McTrain, had talked to several respected plastic surgeons and some of this correspondence mentions the motion picture Face/Off. But as you know under the laws of HIPAA, it would be unethical and extremely illegal for Brad Plaid to get this information. As far as you know, my client (Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter) was talking to these surgeons about himself. For example, he has that mole.

But there is a difference between reaching out for information for face laser surgeries (that  are, by the way, are in nascent stages at at least four other teams in the conference) and implementing "a program" as your disgusting rag puts it. You can make inquiries into anything. For example, Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter can muse publicly about purchasing the Big Galoot sandwich at the Mr. Grundo's near the athletic facility but will never do so because he is specifically prohibited from eating that sandwich by Mrs. "Cudge" Waynegetter due to its violent effect on his bowels that as he put it "shake him up from the insides like a concrete mixer" and he's not allowed to eat it even when she's out of town because she would still know from certain lingering stenches. Would your publication (I hesitate to even call it that) publish a story that Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter has "a program" for ordering the Big Galoot? 

You have 24 hours to remove Brad Plaid's libelous smear against Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter and the entire university before we file an enormous lawsuit upon you. Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter awaits your decision.

Hubert Mant
Mant, Mant, and Vernon

===================================== 

Dear Commissioner Chulbous,

I am writing on behalf of my client Coach Chadd "Cudge" Waynegetter after your inaccurate and slanderous claims in the press that he and Athletic Director Trent Bosphorous have been involved in "secret talks" to move the football team and all athletic programs to the Mountain West and you are prepared to levy heavy penalties against the school. The involvement of my client in any conference-movement scheme is on the face false, and I demand that you retract these claims immediately or face an imminent lawsuit.

We are now all aware of Trent Bosphorous's negotiations with the Mountain West after his months of secret dealings and intricate manueverings with the Mountain West were revealed when he accidentally pressed "reply all" instead of "forward" on an email filled with the incriminating overtures from the conference including the leasing of a custom Mountain West monster truck for the personal use of Mr. Bosphorous. But there is no evidence for the inclusion of my client Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter in these schemes, and he demands the end to these damaging insinuations.

The fact of the matter is that the coach referenced in many of those emails could have been a coach from any of the fourteen varsity sports affected to by proposed move. For example, when you showed a slide from an email at your press conference featuring the pull quote "Coach says we need to get your ass moving before the portal opens up on his ass and his ass will be out there exposed like a naked ass" could have referred to any of these coaches. Perhaps it has escaped the attention of the Commissioner that other sports have a similar portal window such as the fencing team, which has been enhanced by enormous amounts of transfer talent including the great "Swashbuckling" Mallori Gruek (this is just for illustrative purposes, I am not accusing fencing coach Lucinda Mattbottle of anything).

The inclusion of grainy security footage used to insinuate that Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter was at Frunch Steakhouse where Mr. Bosphorous allegedly met with Mountain West officials is in itself libelous and offensive. The footage clearly shows a man in a large hat with glasses, a bushy mustache, and a big rubbery nose entering and exiting the restaurant with Mr. Bosphorous. Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter never wears large hats, only wears reading glasses when his staff prints out the playsheet in type that is too small even though he has told the GAs four hundred times it needs to be at least eighteen point font and he even put a post-it on the printer about it, does not have a bushy mustache, and his nose is much smaller and not rubbery at all. For you to describe it as a "ludicrous disguise" without evidence other than the large mole that Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter has on his face (a very common type of mole that millions of Americans have by the way) is in itself a textbook libel.

Whatever machinations engaged in by Mr. Bosophorous and the Mountain West have nothing to do with my client Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter, and we urge you to make a public correction immediately. Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter has been a loyal member of the conference in his stints at three different schools here; he was even wearing a conference sweatshirt in the video that was illegally leaked of his arrest for driving under the influence for which he was never convicted after agreeing that he was merely "nogged out" after a holiday party.

Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter has been irreparably harmed by your remarks as this will certainly affect his standing in the college sports community. You have 24 hours to apologize to Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter before we file an enormous lawsuit at you.

Hubert Mant
Mant, Mant, and Vernon 

======================================== 

Dear Director Bosphorous,

This letter is to inform you that my client Chadd "Cudge" Waynegetter will be filing a lawsuit to recover the full monies guaranteed to him to buy out his contract. Coach "Cudge" Waynegetter does not believe that running into the offensive coordinator a little bit with the injury cart because he called "an absolute horseshit game" violates the "no hitting clause" in his current contract. 

We will see you in court.

Hubert Mant
Mant, Mant, and Vernon 

Saturday, October 31, 2026

Requiem For the Schiano Men

Last year, it was a matter of a foot or two, the margin by which a Minnesota kick sailed wide of the Wrigley uprights and finally give Northwestern a win in that football-cursed ballpark and a bowl berth. The ‘Cats had been sitting on five wins after shutting out Purdue and suffered three losses in a row including an absolute heartbreaker against Michigan in the unfriendly confines, and desperately needed a win in their penultimate game before having to resort to hoping enough bowl-bound teams would be ravaged by the transfer portal or a coach leaving or an outbreak of a formerly obscure disease called like Footman’s Mumps to sneak into the postseason. On Saturday, the ‘Cats mauled Rutgers and got their bowl berth sewed up. It was not yet Halloween. 

Aidan Chiles again starred for Northwestern while demonstrating the new all purple gothic uniforms are not just good for looking menacing in the library

It is rare for Northwestern to be heavily favored over a Big Ten team and even more rare for them to effortlessly crush them. The game was over in the first quarter when Rutgers proved they had no answer for Aidan Chiles, Caleb Komolafe, and the Northwestern offense and when their starting quarterback suffered a headfirst collision with Kobie McKenzie’s shoulder pad. From my seat in a corner near the apex of the stadium, I was shocked not to see a targeting review or even a penalty flag come out. Unfortunately for Rutgers, the injury wrecked any chance of a functioning passing game; Michael Kilbane got a strip sack on their next possession, and their procession of backup quarterbacks had more success throwing to Northwestern defensive players than star wideout KJ Duff.

Rutgers got within two scores in the second half when Northwestern worryingly stopped playing run defense. The Knights ran for more than 300 yards in this game, which was fine in a game where Northwestern also did that and Chiles scored five TDs through both the air and the ground, but it was a mystifying concern that Northwestern's defense went from virtually impregnable in the first half to looking befuddled that it was legal to run the football.

I did watch a little bit of the broadcast, which was more exciting than the live game only because it had so many shots of Greg Schiano. Schiano’s psychological hold on Rutgers may be fading as the Knights plunge into the depths of the Big Ten toilet from which he was brought in to rescue them, and he is giving a tremendous Embattled Coach Performance out there. He is watching the game squinting under a play sheet he holds up to his forehead as an improvised visor while he makes sour Robert De Niro shouting “Bobby” at Wesley Snipes in the movie “The Fan” faces. He paces around and screams operatic arias at the referees.  


Schiano doesn't wear a hat or visor on the sidelines so it looks like he is often spending the entire game doing this while, I assume, planning to dress as an umpire to attack Wesley Snipes in the rain in the climactic ending to a baseball game. We don't get absolutely insane sports/action movies like this anymore like The Fan or The Last Boy Scout that climaxes with Damon Wayans getting shot through the hand but still accurately throwing a football at a guy with a gun and also features the classic trope of a guy falling off a building into rotating helicopter blades, which is how 95% of 1990 action movie villains were killed, to the point that I think that 1990s action movie villains must have had to have specific Helicopter Blade Insurance

Schiano is cratering at Rutgers, and his time there seems like it might be coming to an end. There are two factors saving Schiano from getting instantly fired: his hefty buyout and the crippling fear that he is the only person who has made it work at Rutgers this century coupled with the fear of the unknown, of plunging into an endless void of bad coaching hires that keep Rutgers in the darkness or actually finding a coach who can have success there but would immediately leave for a program that is not Rutgers, but that calculus has changed now that Rutgers is circling the drain even with Schiano. Schiano is 60 years old and could opt to do something else with his life but he does not strike me as a person who is living unless he is gargoylically stalking the sidelines threatening to headbutt an official or screaming for the punting unit like he is a general ordering a massive strike of conventional weapons on a rampaging godzilla. 

The most lasting legacy from Schiano would be that he reportedly referred to certain players as “Schiano Men” although it is unclear where that came from– all of the reporting on Schiano Men comes from a 2013 Andrew Brandt story in Sports Illustrated about his disastrous tenure with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers  that is no longer on the internet except through the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine where it says “The players also speak to the influx of multiple Rutgers players from Schiano’s past and the use of the phrase 'Schiano Men,' a term that clearly does not apply to [then-Bucs quarterback Josh] Freeman.” To me, it is unclear from this if the Bucs players came up with this epithet as a sarcastic way to identify the coach’s favored Rutgers-seasoned personnel or if it was something Schiano was saying himself, which was the usage I had absorbed from being on the internet at the time and also because the idea of Schiano telling someone "you're not a Schiano Man" is too funny to not interpret it that way.

CHIP KELLY COMES BACK TO OREGON WITHOUT OPERATIC REVENGE SHENANIGANS

Northwestern is 6-1 and ranked, but things are going to get much more difficult. Other than Indiana, Northwestern has been feasting on the worst teams in the Big Ten before getting to the beefy part of the schedule. This includes Oregon, which has spiraled off its preseason number two ranking out of the top 25 altogether. The Ducks are 4-3 and coming off a dispiriting loss in Champaign with the biggest question remaining of whether a game that kicked off at two o’clock central qualifies for “Body Clock” status.

The biggest issues for the Ducks at this part of their agonizing season is who is not available. They lost star quarterback Dante Moore, and Dan Lanning has just fired the offensive coordinator. It’s always a tough question whether you want to face a team that has just fired a coordinator; on the one hand no team that is playing well is firing coaches and there’s a good chance that the hastily-promoted assistant has no idea what he’s doing and is spending the entire time in the booth sweating into a headset microphone like the guy who freaks out at the beginning of Top Gun, but on the other hand it is possible that the previous coach was so inept or toxic or annoying that players are relieved to be rid of him and/or his ineffective or geometrically impossible schemes that they play inspired football.


When everyone is absolutely sick of your lousy offensive coordinator 

Northwestern is familiar with Oregon’s backup after tangling with Dylan Raiola last year when he quarterbacked Nebraska. But he has not exactly had the Oregon offense humming and was briefly benched and reinstated earlier this month. The Oregon offense seems to be coming into this game in complete turmoil and desperation to try to find a way to score points. But Northwestern’s defense will also likely be playing without human missile Robert Fitzgerald and stout tackle Brendan Flakes, and I’m guessing the Ducks will be watching Rutgers get free for enormous runs in the third quarter of the last game and hoping they won’t have the throw the ball much at all.

The Ducks remain a top defense, and it will be up to Chip Kelly and Aidan Chiles to try to solve them. Northwestern has not faced a serious defense since Indiana and struggled against an injury-ravaged Michigan State state team playing out of its mind. I’m not sure what this means for Chip Kelly; it’s been almost a decade and a half since he left Oregon and this seems like a more pleasant reunion than the Shakespearean Michigan State game that had to pause for Pat Fitzgerald and Aidan Chiles and the Crowd as represented by a small chorus of people in Jeff Smoker jerseys to recite soliloquies about the nature of Revenge that end in rhyming couplets

 

O speak me betrayals and sinister plot
Mine email address is hashtag I care not   

For the third consecutive week, Northwestern is relegated to Peacock, which might be unprecedented. The 'Cats certainly got a lot of national games this year, but it is crazy for a ranked Big Ten team to consistently not be allowed on normal television. I have come to the conclusion that Chip Kelly's CFL formations are too controversial and dangerous for over-the-air or normal cable television and may warp the brains of anyone expecting wide receivers to be in a normal place.


The VHS copy of Chip Kelly's Too Hot For TV promises "unbelievable action," "beautiful formations," and "wild feuds with Michigan State"   

The stakes of this game are tantalizing. A win here puts Northwestern on the fringes of the Playoff Conversation which means absolutely nothing in October except for the fact that the square tie knot guys on the college football TV shows have to acknowledge the existence of Northwestern while bloviating about a playoff that will be determined months from now in a hotel ballroom by a secret committee but nonetheless must be bloviated upon. A loss probably takes Northwestern out of that, but still has them primed for an exceptional season with a bowl game and the possibility to do two important things Northwestern hasn’t done for awhile: win The Hat and annoy Iowa. 

But right now, why not dream on Northwestern doing the impossible? When David Braun said in Big Ten media days “why not us” while facing what looked like an impossibly daunting schedule, it seemed like a ridiculous joke. But in a roiling Big Ten marred by injuries and powerhouse programs plummeting from their lofty perches we have a few hours to ask why not us.

FICTION SECTION

The 2026 college football season is about lawsuits and the people who sue each other's asses. Today's short story is the forward to the new college football legal thriller "Motion To Dismiss" by F. Bernard Borticelli.

The question I get most often at book signings or NCAA law events or around town is where I get so many ideas. After all, this is the 74th novel I have published, and the 63rd about the intersection of the law and college sports. And what I tell them is that the world is a stunning, beautiful place with an endless amount of stories to tell, specifically about Trent Thadhill, the greatest legal mind in college sports who is forever battling against the most diabolical boosters, athletes, and coaches who are up to no good. Hardly a day goes by where I don’t think about a Thadhill story, and I must write them down in books because my wife says I am not allowed to talk about them over dinner anymore and I’ve already been divorced twice.

We live in a world surrounded by imperfect justice– systems that let us down, institutions that fail us, institutions that, for example, would allow a college basketball player to accept a tostada-style sandwich and escape without punishment. That was actually something I read about that found its way into “Throwing The Hammer: A Trent Thadhill Novel.” But in my book, this is not merely a free tostada, but it is a front for an operation that lures college athletes into an international pickpocketing ring that uses their track and field skills to separate tourists from their valuables. So when Trent Thadhill is able to use his legal skills to bring the perpetrators to the stand and tearfully confess, he is at least allowing readers to escape into a world where justice exists for people around the world who went to look at their watch only to see it snatched by an All Big 12 sprinter.

I talk to aspiring novelists all the time, and my main advice for them is to keep their eyes, and ears, and noses and hearts open. You never know where inspiration will strike, and you need to be ready to seize it. For example, my second ex-wife had signed us up for some hideous cruise, despite knowing my distaste for loud shirts. Nevertheless, while enduring the most egregious floral patterns over the bosomous torsos of elderly men and accompanying and subjecting myself to the horrors of things like “Bee Gees karaoke night,” the boat did give me the idea for “Maritime Law,” an adventure novel about a basketball player who finds out the NCAA cannot prevent him from importing expensive sneakers as long as he does so in international waters. A minor altercation I had with a man in a truly loathsome parrot shirt inspired one of my most fearsome and popular nemeses for Trent Thadhill, Randy the Tennessee Judge-Shover.

Of course, sometimes your inspiration can simply be looking at the best-seller list for college sports legal thrillers. That is where you get dreck like Walt Grungrueger’s “Ships That Pass” about a rogue quarterback who has turned a disused freighter into an untraceable distribution center for boosters to connect football players with illegal jet skis on the high seas in his Brock McJack series (never mind that I already had published no less than three Trent Thadhill novels where jet skis played key roles including one where he makes a daring escape while dodging blasts from a t-shirt cannon fired by a compromised mascot).

It is to my great disappointment that I have on numerous occasions been asked about a book by someone purporting to be a fan only to discover that it is some Brock McJack offal. I have had enough practice to handle this with grace and humor, but it makes my blood boil to imagine that someone thinks I am responsible for Grungrueger’s leaden prose. My novels are heightened for the sake of entertainment, but are grounded in important legal and ethical issues whereas Brock McJack who is apparently not only a lawyer but a master of some sort of martial art is constantly spin-kicking people. Yes, Thad Thornhill does also spin-kick people, but only does so when it is an exacting part of the legal process and not done just for some cheap thrill.

It is perhaps because he values pure thrills over any thought in our philistine culture that Grungrueger has had such success on the college sports legal novels charts and why they continue to make that imbecilic Brock McJack television series. I have not seen it, but I have seen the commercial that shows a judge saying “overruled” and then firing a bazooka at a gunship helicopter attacking the courtroom because an international gang of street racers cannot afford to have a volleyball player suspended because she is the linchpin of their entire campus operation and also a formidable street racer in her own right even though she is underestimated as a young woman, but they don’t know she comes from a long line of street racers including her brother who was killed by this gang and actually she is secretly working undercover for Brock McJack to get revenge. If this is the type of preposterous claptrap people-- people like my first ex-wife who I understand is an avid fan-- want, then our culture gets what it deserves. I just hope the ignoramuses who watch this schlock understand there is a series of books about NCAA regulations for more discerning intellects, people who understand that it is very rare for a judge to use a rocket launcher and he or she will only discharge one under the most dire of circumstances.

“Motion to Dismiss” is a novel I took painstaking care researching and also one I hope has the types of thrills and adventure that people enjoy in a Trent Thadhill novel. This also marks the debut of Thadhill’s most cunning and dangerous rival yet, a thug who has no respect or knowledge for the law or the NCAA but is nevertheless able to slip through their grasp… that is until Trent Thadhill manages to track him down. I also want to put to bed the rumors that this antagonist Brack McHack takes any inspiration from or has anything to do with Brock McJack, despite what the articles in Legal Thriller Review: A Vance Mantread Publication have to say in their viperous op-ed pages. The names are a simple coincidence; I liked how it sounded and looked in print. The scenes where Trent Thadhill demolishes McHack’s shoddy briefs and dismiss them as “the writing of an illiterate clod or maybe even a goat temporarily turned into a human” are not some sort of hidden dig at Walt Grungrueger. I am not a child. Nor is the part when Brack McHack tries to do a spin kick but badly injures his own testicles any comment on Grungrueger’s work.

I hope you enjoy spending time in the webs of deception and intrigue in “Motion To Dismiss” as much as I’ve relished weaving them.

Friday, October 23, 2026

Pat Fitzgerald and Northwestern Hurl Themselves Off The Reichenbach Falls Into A Giant Toilet

If for many, many years the only way your favorite football team can win a football game is to hopelessly muck things up, play a lot of soft coverage before stiffening in the red zone, and live exclusively by the linebacker and the punt, and the only other football you watch is the pre-Ben Johnson Chicago Bears, at some point you just have to accept the fact that you revel in unwatchable toilet football. That was how Pat Fitzgerald kept getting to bowl games in his 17 seasons at Northwestern and largely how the Wildcats continued to play under David Braun, and this was the operating environment of the Big Ten West; at some point under those conditions, a person who is a fan of a team that does that must accept that the only pleasure you can find as a football fan is appreciating how profoundly annoying your team is and enjoy the psychological distress that your team is causing to another fanbase that assumes that they will automatically win because Northwestern was very bad in the 1980s.


If you see this face you have already punted 

So it was no surprise when a Northwestern team flaunting a great offense for the first time in recent memory, a Northwestern team that had only narrowly lost to the defending champs on the road and was coming in ranked and heavily favored would enter a Spartan Stadium that had been covered in mud and ancient tree traps and Pat Fitzgerald screaming “I’M HERE KILL ME NOW.”


Pat Fitzgerald when confronting an extraterrestrial hunting creature that has just blown up Jesse "The Body" Ventura's rib cage with a futuristic laser weapon

Michigan State, missing something like 45% of its defense (though not former Northwestern linebacker Kenny Soares, who I feel like has been lost in the shuffle in the various Revenge Game narratives– I apologize to Kenny Soares, you may also do Revengeif you would like to), managed to stymie Chip Kelly’s Rube Goldberg offense. They were not fooled by the Wing T and repeatedly sacked former Spartan quarterback Aidan Chiles, who was unable to do much in the first half. Northwestern’s defense, without tackling machine Rob Fitzgerald who is not related to Pat Fitzgerald by the way, let some receivers get behind them for big gains. Michigan State led 14-10 at the half, and it was clear this was going to devolve into a game where both teams Northwestern at each other.

The game turned dramatically on three special teams miscues. Michigan State blocked an early Northwestern field goal attempt. Then, after Chiles led a dramatic late touchdown drive and two-point conversion to tie the game at 21, Northwestern stopped the Spartans and got the ball back to attempt to go ahead. That did not happen. The ‘Cats were stopped deep in their own end and were about to punt the ball back to the Spartans with about three and half minutes left in the game. Instead, Braun, perhaps in a tribute to Fitzgerald, called for the fake punt. I am sure that in seventeen years at Northwestern, Fitzgerald must have called a fake punt or kick that actually worked, but off the top of my head, I can’t remember any. All I can remember are a series of fakes where the upman was given the ball in a futile Charge of the Punt Brigade before being tackled by approximately 85 scholarship players. This time, David Braun called for a variant of this where the upman instead attempted a doomed, wobbly pass to no one.

The stage was set for Pat Fitzgerald to kill the clock, kick a field goal, and (though he would not ever publicly admit it) feel like he has made some sort of point about getting fired by winning one Big Ten game. But that did not happen because of the third special teams mishap, the one I had warned you about in the last paragraph, the one where Brendan Flakes leaped up and battered down the go-ahead field goal and gave Chiles and the Northwestern offense a minute. That’s all they needed. The ‘Cats marched down the field, and Jackson Kleather drilled the 34 yarder to seal it up. Pat Fitzgerald had been out-Fitzgeralded in his new stadium.

The game was a sweet homecoming for Aidan Chiles who had been the starter at Michigan State and in a very 2020s college football twist was facing his former backup for whom he had been benched late in the season. Chiles seemed to get an unwelcome reception from Spartan fans, saying in the post-game press conference that they were chanting “fuck you, Aidan” at him; after Kleather’s kick went through the uprights, the cameras caught him emphatically waving goodbye at the Michigan State stands. This is a weird situation for a few reasons: one is a quarterback somehow finding himself in a better situation after transferring to Northwestern; another is fans getting really mad at a player they didn’t even want on the team anymore coming back and playing for a conference rival. It used to be that fans only got riled up about these kind of things if arcane message board rumors had him signing with a school only to get scooped up by a rival.

I remember seeing Wisconsin native Diamond Stone heckled at a Badgers home game for choosing to go to Maryland and probably also to determine whether it is more satisfying to say "Diamond Stone" in a Wisconsin or Maryland accent

While the ‘Cats and Spartans were busy melting down at each other in a fit of emotional pique, the top echelon of college football was destroying itself. The highest ranked teams in the nation were busy falling apart in a chaotic carnival of the unranked. Amidst all of the chaos, Northwestern went up one AP ranking to number 24; the voters saw a team needing a miracle to escape from one of the Big Ten’s worst teams, ignoring the game’s operatic register. After a crazy and draining game, the ‘Cats face a potentially devastating trap game against the absolute dregs of the conference.

GREG SCHIANO AND RUTGERS ARE TRYING TO PAINT A TRAIN TUNNEL ON THE SIDE OF A MOUNTAIN THIS WEEK

Rutgers might be the only football program whose relationship to its head coach reminds me of Rasputin’s relationship to the Romanovs. Schiano has maintained a bizarre, mystical hold over the program by making the team bowl eligible in the early 2000s. Schiano’s success at Rutgers was so unexpected and celebrated that he left to give the Tampa Bay Buccaneers MRSA. The entire time, Rutgers was pining for him as the program plunged back into misery under Chris Ash while Schiano got fired from the Bucs, coached defense for Ohio State, and repeatedly threatened to take the New England Patriots defensive coordinator job before it became a sinecure for Belichick’s various upsetting sons. But in 2020, Schiano returned to Rutgers to lead them back from being the laughingstock of the Big Ten to the heights of mediocrity as promised in the Prophesies of Schiano.


Schiano in his triumphant first stint at Rutgers where he could be pictured with James Gandolfini looking exactly like a Desperate Gambling Guy in an early Sopranos episode where he has no idea that Paulie Walnuts is going to hit him with a wrench

But even the powers of Pisacataway’s favorite son seem to be waning in 2026. Rutgers got blown out by traditional FBS doormat UMASS, a team that was historically so bad that I started a blog post about the terrible 2019 Northwestern team somehow being favored by 40 points against them by typing "UMASS, light of my life, fire of my loins. My sin, my soul. U-MASS. The lips taking two steps to bleat out and hiss on the second syllable U MASS.” UMASS has actually been surprisingly good this season, racing out to a 4-0 record, but Rutgers was also bludgeoned by a Boston College team in the death throes of the Bill O’Brien tenure. This is one of the worst teams in the Big Ten.

On the other hand Rutgers has not been an automatic out in the conference. They took USC down to the wire in a cross country Body Clocks classic and are coming off their lone Big Ten win by beating a Maryland team that was flashing red like a video game boss low on hit points. The loss to Rutgers, a sort of rival in that they were both part of the third wave of pointless Big Ten expansion as the conference grabbed at lousy teams in a dispiriting desire for East Coast television markets, was the final straw for Mike Locksley. Locksley had gotten Maryland a few bowl wins, but the person who edits Lockley's wikipedia page and writes entire paragraphs about each of his seasons could only describe the 2025 season with the sentence “Locksley returned as head coach for Maryland in 2025 for his seventh season.”

Northwestern is heavily favored at home against Rutgers. This is a dangerous game. Northwestern’s offensive line was battered and beaten up against an injury-riddled Michigan State defense, and the Wing T is not going to take anyone by surprise anymore. Northwestern's wounded secondary has to face Rutgers's excellent receiver KJ Duff, and the Scarlet Knights have a veteran quarterback in journeyman Dylan Lonergan, an Alabama backup who came to Piscataway via Boston College– yes, I checked to see if Lonergan got a Michigan State "fuck you"-style reception from BC fans in his return to Chestnut Hill but he was apparently injured for that game and I can’t find a record of whether BC fans were giving him the business and yelling “I er ah do not care foah this Lonahgan fellow” at him in street clothes on the sidelines while his backup threw four interceptions.

A win here would already make the ‘Cats bowl eligible. Looking at the schedule before the season, I thought just getting to a bowl would be an incredible achievement because I did not realize that Penn State is now a hollowed out disaster that goes out there every week looking surprised that opponents are allowed to run the ball. But that was also because after this game things get serious– they face a Halloween game on the road at what looks like a diminished but still solid Oregon, home against traditional Big Ten West foe Iowa, and then on the road at Ohio State before finishing up against a confounding Minnesota team and an unpredictable Hat Donnybrook against Illinois so if Northwestern does not win this game they could be in last year’s excruciating position of desperately trying to get to Detroit for weeks at a time. 

But with Northwestern playing well and major questions from the Big Ten contenders left on the schedule, some fans are dreaming much larger than a low-tier bowl berth. There's a lot of dragons left on the schedule before I will start thinking about anything more, but this also looks like it could be a special Northwestern team. 

FICTION SECTION

In 2026, college football mostly a collection of lawsuits. Here is a short story about one of the greatest legal minds in college football. 

The case had already pinballed through stays and injunctions and open letters to the media by the time that the partners decided it was time to see The Moose. The Moose was once the most feared litigator in any case touching college sports, a relentless force that could bend any courtroom to his will. But The Moose was retired. The man who had once charmed juries and thundered at judges had become a recluse, only occasionally deigning to offer advice from his office that no one ever saw him enter or leave. 

No one at the firm wanted to see The Moose. He had become irascible and unpredictable, and while The Moose still had what I was told was invaluable insight and advice, he was also liable to berate anyone who saw him and throw them out of his office if they brought a problem he thought was beneath his concern. It was nearly impossible to determine what he thought would merit his attention, and he did not defer to rank or position. One time a high-ranking partner, a man whose name was on the building and whose interactions with anyone who was not desperately trying to please him had dwindled to other motorists who gave him the finger after he cut them off in his car with its signature JURIS license plate had to retreat from a hail of staplers thrown by The Moose who dismissed him as a “certified Brain Idiot.” No one ever figured out how The Moose had obtained so many staplers.

The way it worked is that we all wrote our names on pieces of paper and threw them into a modified t-shirt cannon that we had purchased for this purpose and fired them into a wall covered in sticky paper, and whoever’s name got stuck had to go see The Moose. It will come as no surprise that we had to come up with elaborate rules because of immediate and rampant cheating– now the paper had to come from a single source to stop participants from using heavier letterhead and all of the paper had to meet a four step crumpling process after an intern was found with an aerodynamic origami book that was concealed within a hollowed out collection of case law. I had never bothered to cheat because I subscribed to a fatalism that the universe would decide when to make me face The Moose, and so I didn't yell or fall to my knees or vomit like so many others whose paper had stuck.

Recently, I was told, The Moose had developed very strong opinions on fabrics. He allowed no polyesters, rejected certain cotton blends, and had a very stapler-heavy reaction to certain kinds of wools. “There’s more than one kind of wool?” I asked. “You have no idea,” I was told.

The Moose eventually reached a compromise with the rest of the firm after one person came to see him stark naked. From then on, all visitors had to wear a sort of heavy vinyl smock over their clothes that would prevent his exposure to offending linens or gabardines.

I was led to the two enormous doors in front of The Moose’s office. H. K. R. Theodore Jentamucz, Esq. on the nameplate. He used to have a secretary, but the increasingly complex rules for entry had gotten too unwieldy for anyone but a dedicated employee. At one point, I was told that The Moose would not see anyone who had consumed mustard within the last month, and he demanded that all persons with business before him must undergo a three-week “mustard cleanse.” An associate who had come to see him about a difficult burrito payment case before the NCAA that had reached a snag– cash payments, the burrito completely consumed, a hostile player refusing to yield a stool sample for burrito residue testing– had cheated by a day was met by The Moose bellowing that the firm had sent him a “mustard creature.” “The stuff is oozing from his pores,” The Moose yelled while blasting him with a fire extinguisher.

I knocked in the pattern I was told to and said the phrase “the smog is fog upon the bog.” The doors opened slowly. I was told once that it took three attempts at installing an automatic door opener to match the dramatic pace The Moose demanded without taking forever, but that is a contentious story around the office. The Moose sat behind an enormous wooden desk with papers piled up in the corners. Behind him was a massive portrait of him sitting behind the desk with the same papers and the same portrait that continued recursively, each portrait showing a younger version of him as his muttonchops turned from a pure white into a deepening red as it receded into tinier dimensions. The office was warm and I began to sweat under the vinyl smock. I had heard that he had relaxed the mustard prohibition after undergoing a series of exercises, but I ate my turkey sandwich dry as a precaution.

“Another one,” he said in what was once a powerful baritone but had thinned out and now had a slight wheeze. “I managed to have a long glittering career before the NCAA without having to constantly go barging into someone’s office and begging for help. Used to think through problems myself. Take, for example, Wayne Arizona. Power forward. Mr. Basketball. We had him dead to rights on the car, we thought. Brand new Alpha Romeo sports roadster in Carolina blue. But the paperwork was perfectly in order. They had it in the grandma’s name, you see. Not only that, but they got the old bat race car certified. There were checkered flags all over the house, driving goggles, the whole thing. Someone taught her how to do donuts in a parking lot. Had me up for weeks, pacing. The NCAA was done, you understand. They were totally out of their depth. A bunch of pants merchants over there. They were sending their people down to the DMV, to the title office. 

I said to them, bring me the car. I had some friends down at the local pep boys, game them a few bucks, you know how it goes, or maybe you don’t, you’re probably just pecking away at that computer all day, but I had those pep boys break the whole thing down piece by piece, carburetor to glove box. And that’s when we found it. A receipt from Randy’s Lunch Munch for meatball sandwiches with the name Bunch on it, that had to be Smack Lancaster, an assistant coach. He couldn't resist giving them Steve, he's the only Smack around, and with a certain predilection for the pressed and balled up meats, you see. Grandma admitted she had heartburn in a deposition, she couldn’t handle even half of a Randy’s. Well, when I was done with him, Mr. Arizona never played a minute. Last I heard he was selling high-end custom shoe inserts, doing very well for himself, I understand. That’s what we do here at this firm. That’s the expectation.”

“Or take Rick Cabinet,” The Moose said, barely looking at me. “Quarterback. Sued the NCAA after getting caught with a custom racing airboat from Larry Matador, the airboat king of southwestern Louisiana and a major booster at Western. Said he was entrapped by overzealous NCAA investigators tipped off by Mississippi rivals. There were hours of tapes of him refusing to take the boat saying ‘Sir, that is not allowed by the by-laws of the National Collegiate Athletics Association.’ But he finally took the boat. What he said was that certain rivals had goaded his father into a ruinous air boat race for the stakes of the family bar and grill. Only he, Rick Cabinet, felt like he could guide a supercharged airboat through those swamps fast enough to save the place. The whole thing was a setup. It was a tough time for the NCAA, you see. A few investigators had just been caught planting hamburgers on the Peranta brothers.

It was a good case. The kid was like a stone in his deposition. But what he didn’t know is that I had one of my guys, young hotshot like you probably, working undercover in the high-stakes airboat racing underground. And what he was telling me was a completely different story. Rick Cabinet wasn’t some innocent kid. He was a degenerate airboat racer and not nearly as good as he thought he was. Owed money to all sorts of swamp syndicates. The whole racing to save his daddy’s bar and grill was a bunch of nonsense he and his sumbitch lawyer Bennett Manmancer came up with. You have no idea what we were up against back then. That Manmancer once invented an entire multistate group of vintage burlap sack enthusiasts including handwriting months worths of ‘zines– that’s a homemade magazine, you write it out and put it through a copier– in order to prove why his client had several burlap sacks with dollar signs on them in his garage after committing to A&M. 

But what my guy came up with after months undercover was this.” The Moose began rooting around his desk through mountains of paper breathing heavily and cursing under his breath. Eventually, he pulled out a crumbling, yellowed paper in a plastic sleeve. He frisbee-tossed it over to me and I caught it in a sort of clapping motion after which he yelled at me “what on earth are you doing, haven’t you ever handled a sensitive document before? You’re grabbling at it like you’ve got scissor hands. That was a movie, you understand, there was a pale sensitive boy who had scissors for hands. It's impractical. Cumbersome, as you can imagine.” I looked at the paper while he was berating me and though it had faded and crumbled at the edges, it was clear what it was: a flier advertising an upcoming airboat race featuring the stars of the circuit Ed Tembley, Mead Pohoga, Wayne “Ayne” Cain, and finally in the smallest type on the flier, Rick Cabinet. 

“There it is in black and white. You see, he was already entered in the race, daddy or no daddy,” The Moose said. “The flyer was put up weeks before any bet when he was already secretly negotiating with Matador through a series of hand signs while he was swearing he wouldn’t take the boat into the wire Matador was wearing. 

You should have seen Rick Cabinet’s face when I produced that at his deposition. I’ve never seen a human being turn that shade of green before. Manmancer gave him the thumbs down like he was a Roman emperor making a decision on a gladiator. Cabinet broke instantly. We never heard from him again. I assume the swamp syndicates go their hands on him. Sad story, great arm, just loved the boats too much. Not uncommon, unfortunately.”

He finally stopped talking and glowered at me. I didn’t want to say anything to break into his monologue and didn’t dare interrupt him. But after a minute or two, it was clear he was finally ready for me to speak.

“Thank you, Mr. Jentamuscz for…” I started to say but he immediately interrupted. 

“Out with it already,” The Moose yelled. “Here I am taking all afternoon to tell you about how we win cases at this firm and you’re standing there with your mouth hanging open like a muppet. That’s one of those puppets that Jim Henson made, they had a frog and a pig and all sorts of other creatures,” he said. I knew what a muppet was.

“Sorry, sir, what I meant to say is that we have a somewhat delicate case, one that has everyone here a little perplexed…”

“Let me guess: you’ve got a car someone paid for. Someone bought a couple of pinatas to a children’s birthday party, the good ones, not the new ones where you pull out the ribbons. Did you know they do that now, they pull out the ribbons instead of hitting it with a stick?”

“No, it’s none of those things…”

“Meat importation. Wing tipped shoes. Illegal pythons. I can do this whole case in 35 seconds. Come on, let’s get this over with, I’m a busy man.”

“Mr. Jentamuscz, we are representing a school who wants to play a quarterback that was caught gambling on his own team.”

The Moose, who was noisily shuffling papers while I was trying to talk, stopped and looked at me. “Well you’re screwed,” he said.